Showing posts with label Hong Kong. Show all posts

Cities Compared: Dubai, Hong Kong & Singapore

Singapore Skyline. My second home since 2011.

“So among the cities you have lived at, which one is the best?”

I often come across this question and it always catches me off guard, like in a normal conversation and you have to respond quickly. To be honest, I actually never given a thorough reflection the answer to this. I think I'd rather be asked "Which city do I prefer to live at?", because after all, these cities are equally great in their own ways. So to best answer this long sought query, I will compare Dubai, Hong Kong and Singapore  based on my own experience.

Cost of Living


The first thing that everyone would have to consider when deciding to live abroad is the cost of living. At first I thought as long as I can pay my rent, utility bills and I have enough allowance for my grocery, food and transportation - that's it, I'll get by. But in reality, these are just the basic stuff you need to look after at every month's pay check. You have to consider as well, what I'd call "entertainment" - dining out, going out with friends, watching movies and all other activities that you'd do to keep your weekends occupied. I would add shopping as well because once in a while you'll have to buy something for yourself- whether it's a necessity or just luxury. You didn't just move abroad to just work. Apart from anything else, you will need a social life, a normal life outside of work, and this costs money too.


All of the three cities I have lived at are considered to be expensive. In fact, Singapore currently holds the title as the most expensive city in the world,(Source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-31689124) which easily rules it out on this comparison. So it all comes down between Dubai and Hong Kong. I don't remember the exact figures any more so I will just have to base it roughly how much I spent monthly from my faint memory. The only figures I am sure that are accurate back then are the rent and utilities. However, these may have changed by now as well.



I was really quite careless when it comes to my expenditures back then and didn't keep tabs. But I can say that Dubai is the least expensive city to live at for me back then- given that it is after all a tax-free city. Hong Kong and Singapore are comparable but I have to agree that Singapore is still the most expensive. The figures above might not agree with my statement but then again, it still all depends on someone's lifestyle and way of spending money. In Singapore, I'm mostly out with friends so I was spending more. The room rent also varied on the location, like take for example in HK, I was living in the Midlevels so the rent was pricey but it was closer to my work place so I saved a bit of time travel and transportation allowance. 

Hypothetically, if I was to assume I was earning the same amount of money for each city and compare how much more money is left for me to save and spend after paying all my monthly dues, I had a lot more to save and spend when I was in Dubai. 


Location & Surroundings

Since Dubai is the farthest among the three cities from the Philippines, I didn't like its location. I only get to go home once a year for three weeks and it was really never enough to make up the 11 months I was away on a different time zone.

Singapore and Hong Kong are both closer to the Philippines, allowing me to travel more often back home especially on long weekends. Their locations make them good travel hubs as well which made my travel plans easier and convenient to arrange.


Hong Kong skyline. View from Victoria Harbour

When it comes to surroundings and overall vibe of the city, all of them had their own appeal to me. I would always think of Dubai's grandeur, Hong Kong's colorful and lively streets and Singapore's clean and green roads. 

For this, I would give both HK and Singapore a point each.




Weather


Dubai was ridiculously hot and uncomfortable especially during summer so obviously I dislike its weather.


The desert of Dubai


Singapore has a very unpredictable weather. Like in a day, some parts of it will be sunny, while other parts will be rainy. I can't even rely on its weather forecast any more.

Hong Kong has the complete seasons - winter, spring, summer and fall. So I think weather-wise I like Hong Kong more. There's just always something to look forward to when the season changes.


2011 Winter in Hong Kong.

Transport System

I have never driven any car and as embarrassing as it may seem, I don't even know how to drive. 

Back then in Dubai, you would definitely need a car. I only remember taking the public bus once from office going home. The 10-minute journey by taxi or car took almost more than 30 minutes by bus! So most of the times I would just take a cab, even in walking distance places (especially if it's summer - because it is unbearably too hot to walk outside). 

Singapore has a very good public transportation and most of the times are very efficient. What I like about commuting in Singapore is you can actually check for the timings of the next bus and train arrival which is very convenient for commuters. 

Hong Kong has a very flexible public transportation - from buses, mini buses, trams, taxi, the metro and even ferries- it's so easy to get around and quite cheap too.


Mini Bus, a very reliable mode of transportation in Hong Kong.

So for the ease and comfort of getting around the city and the variety of transportation system you can take, I would choose Hong Kong.



Safety

As a single woman living abroad, most people see it as a vulnerability to threats. But believe it or not, in the past 9 years that I have been living overseas, I honestly did not need to worry about my own safety. Sadly I even feel more threatened in my own country every time I go home. Dubai, Hong Kong and Singapore all promote a safe and healthy environment for everyone.

People & Multicultural Environment

I find Dubai and Singapore have an evident multicultural diverse community compared to Hong Kong. What I found hard in blending in Hong Kong was the language barrier especially at work. In terms of social engagements and events, I find that there are more events and happenings in Singapore that I was able to see. In terms of interacting with the locals, I find Singaporeans are more easier to approach to compared to the locals in Dubai and Hong Kong.



Multi-Cultural Work Environment in Dubai



Work Visas and Residency

I was granted three years of work visa (which includes residency) in Dubai, whilst in Hong Kong, I only had a year. They offer permanent residency only if you have lived there for 7 consecutive years (unfortunately, I only lasted for a year). Singapore has quite stricter policies when it comes to foreign employees. Even if you are already hired by the company, your fate still relies whether the government would approve your work pass or not, and only then you are allowed to work. Permanent residency have to be applied and granted by the government but not all those who apply gets approved. So I would choose Dubai for the fact that they were more lenient when it comes to work visa approvals back then.


Sense of Belonging

Being a stranger in a foreign land hasn't always been as easy as some may think it is like traveling. There's always that feeling of indifference and trying to blend into a culture that you were never familiar with. There is no manual on how to survive living abroad, each one of us has a different approach into trying to fit in and get by. You'll be looked at differently, maybe mocked at and be judged just by the way you look and how you stand out in the crowd. Even if I have already spent a lot of years living in different cities with different culture, I will always be an outsider. 

Dubai was quite challenging for me to live at because it was a lot of first times for me. First time to travel outside of the Philippines and to live by myself. Homesickness was very difficult to overcome. Plus the fact that it is a Muslim country where almost every move you make, every word you say and even what you wear in public is carefully being looked at. I think what helped a lot for me to settle in is the fact that I had a Filipino family there when I moved in. Personally, I really think it helps me settling in knowing that I know people from back home. It just makes me feel comfortable there is a Filipino community I can be part of. 

The total independence combined that with my curiosity made me stay there for three years. But did I feel like I belonged there if I didn't know anyone from back home? I didn't think so.

Language barrier in HK was my greatest challenge especially at work wherein most meetings I have attended were in pure Cantonese. I may have blended well with my Asian features and was easily mistaken as a local, but I stretched out one year to try to live there but on my third month I already wanted to leave. That frustration added by the fact I was recovering from a terrible heartbreak made me decide to fly to Singapore.

Singapore has been my home for four years now and so far, I can feel a sense of belonging in its community. It might be that because I have my family and a lot of good friends here, which really add a lot of factor to one's happiness and contentment. Do I see myself living here for another year or more? Absolutely, as long as my work pass allows me to. 



The Score

1. Cost of Living - Dubai
2. Location and Surroundings - Hong Kong & Singapore
3. Weather - Hong Kong
4. Transport System - Hong Kong
5. Safety - All three
6. People - Dubai & Singapore
7. Work Visas & Residency - Dubai
8. Sense of Belonging - Singapore

All are equally tied!

I believe 'sense of belonging' greatly defines how you would like a city to call it your second home. You could be living in the most livable city in the world but if you are unhappy then it's pointless. Home is not particularly a place, but rather a feeling of belonging.

I have been blessed to have lived in these amazing cities and it might be unfair to compare them. But these are all based on my personal experience and preference. I have actually met a lot of people who both lived in HK and Singapore and they prefer HK more. 

Singapore may be the most expensive city to live at, the most difficult to get a work visa and Permanent Residency approval but if it makes me feel at home and happy then it already won my heart a million times over.


Cavenagh Bridge at Singapore River
Photo Credit: April Anne Loayon

>>> Read More about Life in...

Dubai

Hong Kong

Singapore

From Middle East to the Far East

Hong Kong (2010-2011)

October 2010 The Victoria Peak, Hong Kong
The first time I have been to Hong Kong was way back in early 2009. I was flying back to Dubai from a vacation in the Philippines and had a long layover so I decided to get out and explore a little bit of it. 

All I knew of Hong Kong is Disneyland, but I knew my time wouldn't be enough to go there. So randomly, I grabbed a flyer from the airport and checked what are the nearby places I can go to. But then I found out that HK island is quite far from the airport, so there is no place that could be considered "near" for a quick trip. The Peak caught my eye.



It was freezing cold when I got there and winter was probably at its peak. Wishfully thinking, I said to myself that perhaps it would be great to live in there. It was just so beautiful and the cold weather was inviting, something that's missing in Dubai. Little did I know that random thoughts and wishes like these would lead me back to Hong Kong a year after to actually live in there! So much for wishes do come true.

View from The Victoria Peak 
Behind me is the Peak Tower

Dubai was blown hard by the economic recession in 2008. The company I was working for was no exception. We lost a handful of employees and I got scared for my own place. So after my Christmas holiday in 2008, I returned to Dubai with a resignation letter on my hand. I have decided I wanted to move to Singapore, where my brother and a few of my high school friends have already moved to. I reasoned out it was closer to home and that I just felt like my time in Dubai has come to an end. It was a good three years and I was ready to go wherever fate would take me next.

There's a part of me that feels I am getting fed up of Dubai and just wanted a change of scenery. I was offered to stay but I just really wanted to go. I think when your desire to leave a place is stronger, your eyes are shut to see what else is around you that may convince you to stay.

So they offered me to move to Hong Kong instead. If I was just really considering its proximity to my home town, it is actually closer compared to Singapore. So I took the offer. I just cant believe a year before that I was wishing I could live there, and Viola! The Universe has responded.


There is a huge difference between visiting a city and actually living in there. When you are a tourist, you only get to see all the nice places, stay in there for a couple of days and then you leave with all the good impressions you have for that city. You view it differently because everything looks sparkly and new to your foreign eyes. But to actually live in there is a totally different story. I had to learn this when I moved to Hong Kong.

Hong Kong Central


* Facts about Hong Kong

* Hong Kong means "fragrant harbour".

* It was a British colony for 156 years and on 1997, was handed over back to its motherland, China. It has then been called Hong Kong SAR (Special Administrative Region).

* It is one of the densely populated cities in the world.

* Hong Kong is a world city. It is one of the Al­pha+ cities, along with London and New York City, which forms the most influential and important cities in the global economy.

* It has four main islands: Kowloon, Lantau Island, Lamma Island and Hong Kong Island.

Outlying Islands
Photo Credit: Discover Hong Kong
                         
* The local language is Cantonese. Though most of the locals can speak Mandarin too.

* The locals prefer to call themselves Hong Kees than Chinese.

*Source: Wikipedia, personal observations.

First Impressions

Wan Chai Area, Hong Kong

When I moved to Hong Kong in 2010, I had that same feeling when I've first been there during a layover in 2009. I was excited. I was in high spirits, everything was just new to me. And then it hit me the actual difference of just visiting and actually living in the city.

I find Hong Kong a city that is really busy and seems to never gets tired. Even at night, it is still full of life and lights and it felt like it was so wrong to sleep so early while the city is still so much awake and upbeat. It is indeed a City that seems to never sleep.

It feels congested too in terms of actual "space". You won't see much land spaces on Hong Kong island alone, there are just buildings or establishments everywhere to maximise every corner of it.

Adjusting to the New Environment

I think my main problem when moving to a new city is I don't really make a thorough research. At that time, my priority was just to move out of Dubai and land somewhere with a secured job and that's when Hong Kong presented itself. I did try to ask former colleagues in Dubai who also moved to Hong Kong and got a few pointers and description of what it has been like for them. But I guess everyone has a different vantage point.

Language barrier made it very difficult for me to settle in. Most of the people are poor in speaking English. I was really surprised by this to think HK was once a British colony. Since I am Asian, people assume that I was a local and so they speak to me in Cantonese. At first, I was okay with it, having to explain that I am not Chinese and I don't speak any Cantonese. But it really gets frustrating later on, like when you really just wanted to go to a place and the taxi driver can't make out of what you are saying, when you are deliberately speaking in English and they still respond in Cantonese. Sometimes, I had to get help from my boss, who is a Hong Kee, to write down for me in Cantonese the places I wanted to go to so I can just show it to the taxi driver to make it easier for the both of us. 

Even at work, I felt really out of place. I had to attend several meetings in Cantonese (or Mandarin, I can't tell the difference). It was frustrating and my boss had to translate to me afterwards in like three or four sentences. 

Believe it or not, I even actually missed speaking Tagalog, (my mother tongue). There was just no one to talk to or share how your day has been, so most of the times I would call my friends just to hear myself speaking in my native tongue. I think whenever I am in another country, somehow, I still long for Filipinos just to give me that comfort and feeling that I am never far away from home.


Looking over Hong Kong's skyline at Victoria Peak

I started missing the diversity of culture in Dubai. At work, there were only a few expats like me (around 10 I think) and most of them are Westerners and managers and the rest are all Hong Kees that tend to stick with their group. There were a few Filipinos but I have met them when I was already about to leave Hong Kong. So most of the times, I have eaten lunch alone, which I was not really used to. Back in Dubai, we had this huge Filipino group and we ate lunch together. I started feeling homesick of Dubai and the friends I have made back there. 

Depression, loneliness, homesickness, that feeling of isolation, that lack of sense of belonging and a heartbreak over a failed relationship made me leave Hong Kong a year after. The circumstances around me and the experience I've had of living there gave me a different view of Hong Kong, something that I didn't see when I was just visiting it. I am not saying living in Hong Kong was a bad experience for me or it is not a good city to live at. I think every person deals differently when they're out of their comfort zone. 


Dark clouds hovering over Victoria Harbour.
Such a drastic difference of view when the sky is blue.

If there's anything I have learnt and I am grateful for of my time in Hong Kong is that it taught me how to do things even on my own and still enjoy it. Only in Hong Kong have I started to watch movies alone, to eat out alone, even to watch concerts alone (yes, twice!), to hang out at the beach alone, travelled solo to Phuket, etc. These things that I didn't even dare to try to do before because I have always had someone to do it with.


I have come to appreciate the beauty of solitariness. I had so much time on my hands that it gave me a great opportunity to start doing the things I wanted to do but I am always putting off. I signed up for a yoga class, I volunteered at Hong Kong Dog Rescue, I started (but still failed) swimming lessons. 


Taking a moment watching the placid waters at Stanley beach.

To be fair, I did make a few good friends in Hong Kong. I'd like to think that I struggled mostly in finding common interests amongst the people I have met, mostly Brits or Asians who were brought up in the UK. There were just some things that I can't relate to with them like in terms of food, TV shows to watch, music, things to do on the weekends, etc. These simple things that you talk about to try and find some ground to connect to another person. I think I'm too Americanised that I mostly felt out of place.

There is somehow a bit of racism against Filipinos that I felt when I was there. The perception of most of the people have there is that when you are a Filipino, they would immediately assume that you are working as a domestic helper or at the "bars". It was uncomfortable to say the least, when people make comments whenever they find out that I am a Filipino but I am neither of those they think I would be. Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against the Filipino workers. It's just disappointing whenever people look down on you or judge you by the colour of your skin and by what you do in life.



The People, Lifestyle, Culture, Cost of Living (Then), Etc.


The beautiful Hong Kong Park in the middle of skyscrapers in Central, Hong Kong
One thing I admire about the Hong Kees is their efficiency to get things done. This is how dedicated they are in providing services for everyone. Take for instance, ordering a food or when I renewed my work visa. I don't remember having to queue for long. One thing I observed though is that they mostly don't smile or make eye contact with you and I felt like they were a bit snobbish. I asked my boss about it and he said it's how they get things done, they don't like the idea of seeing other people wait behind you, so they try to get things done as fast as they could. One thing you won't see happening when you are in the Philippines.


Another thing I noticed at work is they don't leave on time. On my first few weeks, I was the only one leaving at exactly 5:30 PM! I felt embarrassed and started asking my other colleague, who is a Brit. He said he was the same as me when he started, a bit culture-shocked. According to him, most of them stay longer because they don't want to go home just yet as most of them are still living with their parents (common Asian trait) or they just pretend to be working to impress their superiors even though they are just browsing the internet. I am not sure what is the truth behind this or if it was just their thing. I didn't dare to ask any of my colleagues back then. 

In terms of cost of living, I find Hong Kong more expensive than Dubai. I used to live in Hong Kong island, Central Mid-levels. The room I was paying for is *HKD 6,500 (USD 800 ; AED 3,000). My room was even smaller compared to the one I had in Dubai. Well, everything is smaller in Hong Kong because of the little land area it has. I like the vicinity where I used to live at. It's very close to everything and all within walking distance - grocery stores, salons, gym, Catholic church, Lan Kwai Fong (which is the popular party place in Hong Kong), streets and streets of food places. My office was just about 10-15 minutes away.


 Central Mid Levels, Hong Kong
The Central Mid-levels Escalator
 The world's longest outdoor covered escalator system, stretching for over 800-metres and rising 135-metres 

Food is cheap especially if you don't mind street foods. There are a lot of food options in Hong Kong, but one thing I found difficult when dining out was that most of the menu are written in Chinese. They do post pictures of the food so mostly I relied on those to see which one looks delicious. Noodles and dumplings are the most popular food. There is something different about when you taste (for example) a beef noodle from a Chinese restaurant in Dubai than a beef noodle in Hong Kong. I don't know what it is but for some reasons, I'd like to think a local food becomes more authentic when you eat it at its place of origin. 

Here are some of the interesting buffet restaurants, that offer not only good food but a good view of Hong Kong as well, which I recommend:


Jumbo Floating Restaurant in Aberdeen 
You need to ride a small boat to get to the actual restaurant. It is literally floating in the waters. Best to get a table near the windows to get a good view of the harbour. Most of the foods served are seafood.


R66 Revolving Restaurant in Wanchai
(Photo Credit: 
http://www.panoramio.com/)
View of the city from the Revolving Restaurant. 
This is located at Hopewell Centre, Wanchai where my former office was located as well. A great variety of food is served. You won't actually feel the place moving unless you look out at the windows. View of the city is absolutely amazing. I haven't tried to go up at night but I reckon it would look splendid as well.

If you're not into Chinese food, there are a lot of Western foods and other Asian cuisines such as Thai, Indian and even Filipino, to choose from. There was even a Jollibee outlet there! You will definitely never feel hungry when you are in Hong Kong. Every street, every corner has a food place.


HK Beef Noodles
Jollibee in Central, HK
Getting around Hong Kong was very easy. I personally think you wouldn't need a car. They have a very good train system, MTR (Mass Transit Railway). Other means of transportation are public buses, 5-seater cabs (which are very spacious), LRT (Light Rail Transit) for the farther areas, Trams which are cheap but non-air conditioned and Public Light buses or the mini buses which are all widely available. 

The mini buses have red and green colours and its numbers indicate its route. Their stops are the same as where the buses are, but you can hail and ride them at any corner most of the times. I got a bit disoriented when I first boarded this. Some of it don't have the bell to press to make it stop so you have to shout "Next stop, Please" when you want to get off.


Hong Kong's Mini Bus
Photo Credit: Google Images
HK's 5-seater Red Cabs
Some people consider the Trams are more for tourists rather than a means of transportation. You can actually hire one and host a Tram Party.

Tram(L) and Public Bus(R) in Hong Kong Central.
Since Hong Kong is composed of other outlying islands, you can also catch a ferry and enjoy the scenic view of the its harbours.


Ferry Ride from Hong Kong island to Tsim Sha Tsui
The weather in Hong Kong has the complete four seasons - Spring(March-May), Summer (June-August), Autumn(September-November) and Winter(December-February).

Due to its geographical location, it also experiences typhoons usually during summer. Though in my experience, they were not as strong and violent as the ones we have in the Philippines. They have a different type of categorising typhoon level which really confused me. Having grew up in the Philippines, I only know of Signal 1-5. HK has colour system (measures rainfall) and numbering system (measures the strength of wind) in categorising typhoons.

Growing up in the Philippines, I have never experienced what winter was like. Dubai has a winter season too but it was tolerable, I could just wear a thick jacket and a scarf. I struggled very much to keep warm during winter in Hong Kong. I just didn't know how much layering of clothing I had to wear. I ended up mostly just staying at home because it was too crucially cold for me to go outside. The temperature can get as low as 8 oC to 10 oC in the mornings but it doesn't snow in there. On the brighter side, I enjoyed dressing up during this season. I got to wear my coats, beanies and boots!


Not the best time to go to the beach! :p
(Taken at Repulse Bay)